Debunking the Left’s Class Warfare Rhetoric

Posted 11.15.12 by Todd Cefaratti, Editor of TPNN


President Obama and his Democratic colleagues in Congress are wrong about the fiscal cliff. If we manage to avoid this looming economic crisis that promises to come at the end of this year, we must be willing to do more than slap a Band aid on the problem and then forget about it. Fundamentally, our economic model is flawed and it needs to be fixed. Is Obama up to the challenge?

My guess is no, he is not. The Democrats have been framing this discussion of the fiscal cliff in terms of a one-time problem that needs fixing. It’s not. We need to view this approaching crisis as a result of unsound economics on the part of the U.S. Government.

We need to extend the tax cuts for both the middle class and the so-called “wealthy” as a means of fostering growth down the road. Sure, this will not bring immediate revenue this month, but if President Obama had ever had a real job, he would have learned the value of long term gains compared to short term gains. By shaking down the job creators, Obama and his band of Democrats seem more interested in making a point than doing what will yield results for our economy.

The left scapegoats those that are wealthy. Their agenda is one driven from creating division in America and creating class strife. The argument coming from the left is not one of practicality, but seemingly one derived from a purposeful incitement of resentment for the upper class. It’s a staple of all modern despots who wish to distract the masses from their own ineptitude.

The left doesn’t want to compromise. Allowing us to reach the fiscal cliff allows them the moral high ground to paint the absurd narrative that the Republicans are nothing but irrational obstructionists. Further, it allows them to continue to complain that the rich aren’t paying “their fair share.”

Whilst we negotiate with the hard-line socialists in office, the Republicans need to do a better job painting a fuller picture. We don’t need to simply dodge this one problem, we need to begin to systematically disarm the left-wing rhetoric by outlining the long term benefits of increasing revenue through growth instead of tax hikes.

The GOP needs to explain the complicated issue in easier terms. If we turn the screws on the wealthy- the job creators- we get immediate revenue. They, in turn, do not expand their businesses and hire no new employees. In fact, many are liable to lay-off employees to maintain profitability.

However, if we extend these tax cuts and focus our attention elsewhere- such as cutting entitlement spending- then there’s more money in the pockets of the business owners. Business owners don’t take their money and shove it under a mattress. They tend to reinvest their money into business growth, which usually requires more personnel. These middle class workers then have income and pay taxes, which leads to increased revenue for the government and less people in the unemployment line.

Granted, my explanation is highly simplified, but the point remains the same. If we can simplify this discussion and diffuse the class-warfare-inciting rhetoric from the left by explaining the value of tax cuts for the wealthy, then we can stop the leftist propaganda machine in its tracks.



  • Pingback: Free business html templates 2013 to download

  • Pingback: Southington

  • Pingback: http://answers.yahoo.com/question/index?qid=20130117024653AAv25w7

  • Pingback: fatcow or hostgator

  • Pingback: Prestashop themes 1.5

  • Pingback: 180+ Joomla CMS Themes

  • Pingback: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=939lmV0yrrk

  • Pingback: payday loans

  • Pingback: туроператор по израилю

  • Pingback: Красное море Израиль видео

  • Pingback: Туроператоры по Израилю в Москве

  • Pingback: Израиль Мертвое море туры

  • Pingback: мертвое море цены

  • Pingback: мертвое море

  • Pingback: free wordpress themes for photographers blog

  • Pingback: transfer to FatCow

  • Pingback: κατασκευη φθηνου e-shop

  • Pingback: www.free-credit-report.net

  • Pingback: Morrisville

  • Pingback: kawa lavazza cena

  • Pingback: see our page

  • Pingback: Empower Network

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Joseph-R-Carreiro-Sr/100000561837094 Joseph R Carreiro Sr

    Sowell is an expert on uncovering propaganda.And a Patriot to boot.Good man.

  • http://www.facebook.com/muddnet Scott Taylor

    Thank God for all you fellow Tea Party Patriots…

  • http://www.facebook.com/randall.brim Randall Brim

    Using Romney’s 47% as an example, here’s the problem. Among those 47% are people receiving some form of government assistance who have either actually earned it, or paid into a program for that benefit. This group includes social security recipients, medicare recipients, military personnel, etc. This group is not the problem.
    The problematic group is comprised of those individuals who have taken the social safety net and turned it into a permanent lifestyle choice. Americans are compassionate and there is no objection to helping those who cannot provide for themselves. However, multigenerational families dependent on welfare is unconscionable. Individuals who are capable of of providing for themselves, but simply choose not to, are an anthema to society, irrespective of their race, religion, national origin or any other demographic. To be clear, those who “cannot provide for themselves” do not include indivuduals who through a lifetime of bad choices, find themselves unskilled and illiterate with crimal records. But even for these individuals, there is a way out through hard work and better choices.
    The hard part is convincing those individuals in the latter group that despite their circumstances, free market capitalism provides the only way for their lives to be meaningfully improved. They have to be convinced that conservatives have more failth in their abilities (if put to use) and higher aspirations for their lot in life than liberals, who will give them just enough “stuff” to survive, but never enough escape a life of poverty or near-poverty. Conservatives want everyone to be successful and prosper and none be relegated to a life of dependency. How do we make that point persuasively?

  • princepsCO

    Mr. Sowell may feel that he’s ‘dumbed down’ the description and definition of our economic challenge but I think he’s done an excellent job of describing the situation. I, though, can go ‘dumber’—ask my kids they’ll agree—with the description: IT’S THE SPENDING! CUT $2 TRILLION NOW!

  • http://www.facebook.com/pauline.dion.106 Pauline Dion

    Too bad you couldn’t replace no bama. You have a sense of reality that no bama and his band of idiots don’t have. The financial problem is OVERSPENDING…As children our dad taught us that if the money is not there and you have not earned it you cannot spend it. Period. Why can’t they understand a simple mathematical equation?

  • Deb Roberson

    This message should be shouted from the rooftops, from every news network across this country!! Of course it won’t, because there are very few real journalists left in our country, just a bunch of liberal “groupies” posing as journalists! Dr. Sowell needs to be heard!!!

  • http://www.facebook.com/doan.azzopardi Doan Azzopardi

    The tax cuts for the wealthy never did the country any good. Why keep
    them? On the contrary, they’ve redistributed the wealth so that while the top income groups have become five times as wealthy since 1980, the rest of America hasn’t seen an improvement. This is not a result of the rich working harder or 95% of the population being lazy. It shouldn’t be “socialist” or “leftist propaganda” to point that out.

    I think the Republicans needs to stop their hate-filled rants and sit down at the negotiation table. As Ronald Reagan said:

    http://www.facebook.com/photo.php?fbid=487014874665787&set=a.264248670275743.69392.259536274080316&type=1&theater

    As it is, the people with about 50% of the income contribute less than 40% of the taxes, so they aren’t in any way paying their fair share. Raising taxes back to what they were under Clinton won’t “destroy the United States” or create division. It will simply mean the country can afford to pay its bills and stop the massive redistribution policies of the last 30 years.

    The people at the bottom have been subjected to massive cuts and many are struggling to make it from day to day. If they had a little extra, they would be spending it on things which would make their lives better. That increased demand would lead to more jobs being created.

    Keeping half the population in poverty means low demand and that companies have no need to expand, no matter how many tax cuts you pile on them. If they can’t sell their products, they won’t expand their business.

  • Runninbear

    Or remove all non citizens,who are here illegally who drain the programs that we Americans created for our citizens and not Non citizens that are being given away to some who has broken our laws just to being here.I recent read a fraud going on on income taxes,where Illegals have claimed the child exemption act for children they never have or have never lived in the United States?I think a good place to start is the salaries and benefits that they have given them selves when they make more money with insider trading and other personal appearances and other investments, but they would rather let our own citizens suffer than to support them.Forced Health care that was created behind closed doors and kickbacks,pay offs.That won’t even cover the people it should but those who will get free health care,where no fines and taxes will be required of them!Or even our military suffering when we are in so many uprising and threats by terrorists that the administration would cover up and ask to cut the budget and let our veterans suffer.These are the places you should start but you won’t!

  • Arlene Roberts

    I hope the republican and the good democrats, tell him no about everyuthing’

  • Allan Hamilton

    I don’t believe this article was written by Thomas Sowell and that’s a problem. There is no attribution for the origins of this piece but TPNN has allowed us to “believe” that it was written by Sowell. That’s cute. The fact that no credit is given to the good Dr. is about as good a proof as is needed. Sowell is a nationally known figure and you can bet that any word published by him is visibly credited – most likely by contractual agreement. If he DID write this, then TPNN should be excoriated for printing the piece without attribution. If Sowell DIDN’T write the piece then TPNN should be excoriated for perpetrating a fraud allowing someone else’s work to be considered as Sowell’s. Come clean TPNN…and get your journalistic house in order. This fight MUST remain intellectually honest and above board to have any shot at credibility. And since YOU are in the forefront of this charge, we are going to hold you to the same standards we would the MSM, because that’s the right thing to do.

  • http://www.thinkyhead.com/ Thinkyhead

    Let’s end welfare for the poor states who are taking from the rich states. Let them fend for themselves! Many of these are big Tea Party states, so the’s lots of folks who could get behind this. Get out there and end wealth redistribution now!

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Joe-R-Osegueda/1747463293 Joe R Osegueda

    I agree with the majority of you commenting,this shows what we all know to be true!However I also see a calling here from God on all of us!We seem to all agree,and has been said in many comments we should pray for this to change!Absolutely correct,I believe God allowed this to happen to bring those of us that truly believe in him,to draw us even closer to him,and more in communication with the most high!And those of us that aren’t as close even closer,we need to agree as a whole to pray for our leaders,our country,the people that don’t believe!The main prayer is first that we would ourselves want to be changed even further by God,so then we could see a clearer picture of what we actually need to pray about for this country!God has worked a lot in my life this past year,and showed me the plank in my eye,opposed to the spec in my brothers eye!Now I have a better understanding and thus can see clearer what needs to be brought to God in prayer!And I still have a long way to go for God changing me!Main thing is we all agree to pray as one for our leaders and the blind that follow our corrupt government,from the president all the way down.God wants us to continue to work,create life,plant gardens,and be a blessing to others,and pray for our leaders,and then God will take care of what needs mending,less Jesus decide to show up sooner than later!But know this,all who pray and fully trust God,we will have his hedge of protection,he knows his children’s hearts!Amen!!God Bless All!!

  • Kathy Clanton

    If we want to counter the indoctrination of socialism we need to de-unionize our public schools & open up education to a free enterprise type system, ie: vouchers and school-choice. The left-leaning school system is a breeding ground and a bastion for socialist thought, clear up to the universities. When young people have no other teaching but what is fed to them for 16 years, they come to believe that philosophy as “truth” without question. They are very pliable up to the age of 25 which is why so many “teeny-boppers” voted Obama in 08. In fact I believe it is the only way to reverse the tide of the progressive (sic)-re-gressive lie: re-education/alternative education of our young. I also strongly feel that people should be required to take a course on the Constitution and Declaration of Ind. before being allowed to register as a voter. Even though our kids are supposed to be learning this in school, they’re NOT–they learn more about how to put condoms on bananas, cultural “sensitivity & saving the polar bears than they learn about our country!

  • http://www.facebook.com/tim.pastorino Tim Pastorino

    While simple, and I agree that decreased business investment
    caused by increased taxation ultimately causes decreased economic capability,
    that message is white noise to people swallowing the kool-aid with clear
    messages from dem’s that say “all they (anyone not supporting this message)
    wants to do is take away what we are giving you”. The fear that instills in people who are
    getting handouts for doing nothing is paralyzing and extremely motivating, so
    much so that dem’s have to say naught else.
    The republican message can’t just be “cut X, cut Y, cut Z”; it needs to
    be equally motivating and powerful.
    Messages that rely on people understanding the larger problem,
    understanding that tightening belts is necessary, etc., already lose with a
    base of people that just want to know what and how much they are going to get
    without doing anything for it. And, that
    base isn’t motivated by being told what they won’t get, soon. I don’t know what the answer is, however.

  • http://www.facebook.com/joe.roy.140 Joe Roy

    Did you know that CENTRAL BANKS, where we borrow all of this so called free
    money, are currently dictating to many countries what their domestic and foreign
    policies will be. If those financially strapped countries do not conform to the
    will of the world bank they do not get the money they need. Do you want world
    banks to dictate policy to America? Well if we get in much more dept that is
    exactly what will happen. World banks trade money for power!

  • http://www.facebook.com/joe.roy.140 Joe Roy

    That is well said my friend. The one of the things I have been writing to my
    repersentivates in Washington about is the need to truly explain, in simple
    terms, what the true ideology of conservatism is. The young mistakenly see is as
    attack of their freedom. They focus on gay marriage, abortion and the utopian
    vision of socialism. This of course is the message the democratic establishment
    has been pumping out in lue of the truth. The true is that socialism will
    destroy freedom and remove the middle class. The poor in this country are still
    better off then most other countries middle class. The real disaster of
    socialism is the loss of hope. The very hope that exists in this country that
    created the phrase “The land of opportunity” is a result of capitalism. There is
    no money fairy, the government,, when it prints money, owes that money to
    central banks. The Government does not make anything nor does it produce wealth.
    Business does that and if you take money (profit) from business it does not grow
    and thus cannot afford to hire. We need to truly explain what the republican
    party stands for and explain that it does not take away freedom it stands for
    freedom. Getting mandated contraceptives in your health care is not freedom, the
    ability to work hard and be justly rewarded for that effort with financial
    success is freedom. Having the people run the country is freedom not having the
    government legislate it’s will on them

  • pj

    True very true.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Tom-Harris/1810331814 Tom Harris

    it does not matter how many times you prove it, how much math you use or how much history you show, liberals are to stupid to get it and never ever will get it….ever

    • http://www.facebook.com/julia.patton.902 Julia Patton

      This is one liberal who does get it. It took me a while to get away from that brainwashing rhetoric, my father and grandfather were liberals, devoted. They raised me to thinking they were the right party and stood for the little man and unions, and of course the working poor and poorest of the poor. I am so thankful that I am no longer blinded to the tricks that liberals pull to keep poor people poor and dependent. It isnt right, that is robbing people of their basic rights to work, using their own strength and ingenuity to be a productive and self reliant citizen. It is a crime to treat people like they are too stupid to take care of themselves and the government can do a better job. Thank God I woke up and my mind and vision has been restored.

      • Richard

        Julia===brilliant –just fantastic! We truly rob so many of using their own strength –by keeping them blind and stupid! Why do you think we produce so many high school graduates that can’t add or even tell you where the “Gaze Strip” is? Some idiot on National TV said “OH in Hollywood I think”!! Keep them dumb and pregnant—and dependent on government handouts–and you will control their vote!

    • Richard

      You are so right Tom—most liberals only “feel” they don’t think! They just want to feel like they are doing right! I’ve never seen so many weak & stupid people and I’ve lived a long time! They will live to regret their touchy feelie crap–and so called “social justice”!

  • http://www.facebook.com/sharon.burress Sharon Baker Burress

    I say, give the Democrats everything they want. With this tactic they won’t have the Republicans to blame for their failure and all will clearly see what a failure it is.
    If we win in getting our tax breaks for our job creators without gaining either all the Romney or the Ron Paul strategies, then the national economy is going to fail anyway and they will just blame our one small concession for the fall.

    • http://www.facebook.com/julie.ervin.7 Julie Porter

      That’s what I said. Why can’t we let them do their damage, not have anyone to blame, and then maybe we can regain the Senate and possibly the Presidential race if people blame the right people.

      • Time to start over

        There are 2 problems with this theory;
        1. Just because they fail doesn’t mean they will recognize it. case and point; look at what a miserable failure Detroit is. Their city is in shambles and yet they have not elected a Republican mayor in more than 50 years. They just keep practicing the same failed policy and expecting a different result; Insane!
        2. If we give them all they want there will not be any pieces left to pick up when they are through destroying this great nation!

      • http://www.facebook.com/cary.hanni Cary Hanni

        Because they are damaging my kids and grandkids future.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Steven-West/100001104410627 Steven West

    Unfortunately it is purely a political move. The democrats have figured out that this whole “Robin Hood” thing of take from the rich and give to the poor gets votes…they do not care that it really does not work.

    • http://www.facebook.com/sam.castorani Sam Castorani

      Unfortunately, you are exactly right. And the sad part is that they really don’t care. Well said!!! When you rob Peter to pay Paul, you will always get Paul’s vote!

  • http://www.facebook.com/sue.copeland.129 Sue Copeland

    Thanks for your Common Sense. We are so hungry to hear intelligent, right thinking explained so well.

  • http://www.facebook.com/fmoodiii Floyd L. Mood III

    Yes, the rhetoric must be stopped with the simplecity.

  • StandUpForAmericia

    The only way the socialist can gain any ground is by fear and hate monger. They must create a division so that the lower wage earners and non-working classes will back their agendas. The right has to build a strong backbone and go to the media and debunk the myths the left and socialist are creating. They must stand on firm ground and not comprise values and morals as they have the last 4 years. And WE THE PEOPLE must pray for all of them.

    • http://www.facebook.com/dave.hughes.378 Dave Hughes

      Your thinking is very straight but there is one flaw and that is the “going to the media to debunk the myths” part. Unfortunately the media is a big part of the problem. If they would just report the news, rather than reporting the news that they feel benefits them, this re-education process would work. The news media has become a propaganda machine for the socialists in this country and they have no desire to try and help eliminate the left’s class warfare. But that could change through prayer and you hit that nail right square on the head.

      • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=1632674186 Sandra Gallegos

        We need to totally turn off the TV and cancel any left leaning newspapers. If you don’t watch, they can’t continue to exist. Problem is our children are wedded to and get their news from Reddit, Bill Maher, Letterman, Colbert, and Jon Stewart.

  • top

    Good Job, Would you Consider Running for President?

  • http://www.facebook.com/carol.b.fell Carol Ballinger Fell

    Thomas Sowell for President in 2016!!!!

  • http://www.facebook.com/rin.chapin Rin Chapin

    Part of the problem, however, is that anyone who subscribes to a socialist philosophy does not think that cutting entitlement spending is a good thing. They are accomplishing their goal with alarming success, while convincing non-thinking Americans that is the compassionate, and therefore morally right, thing to do. This is how the Hebrews ended up in slavery in Egypt. How many years will it be before half the population wakes up to realize they are now enslaved through the very “benefits” they wanted? (And hopefully by then it won’t be more than half the population, as times grow more difficult.) We have to start combating the philosophies that are capturing the minds of the next generation. We start by taking a hard, objective look at where those ideas come from, namely education and the media, and making changes in how we participate in those venues.

    • http://www.facebook.com/mark.sabec.7 Mark Sabec

      Very well said. Very well said. Too many people are blinded by the biased media these days. Afraid to think for themselves, just repeat what they hear and call it their argument. Too many people don’t educate themselves – really take a look into what is really happening in our country right now. If more people did take an in depth look at this, hopefully they would see through the lies and make decisions on their own.

      • http://www.thinkyhead.com/ Thinkyhead

        Oh the delicious irony,

    • http://www.facebook.com/clifford.holt.92 Clifford Holt

      Unfortunately, More that half of the people do rely on the government for some or all of their income. With food stamps, welfare, disability (which I’m on), Social Security, government jobs, military, and the myriad of other government aid programs out there. That’s not counting Medicare and Medicaid. So there are a lot of people who, unlike me, can’t see the value in “risking” giving up what they get.

      The real problem is this http://archive.glennbeck.com/news/03212002.shtml

      • http://www.facebook.com/rin.chapin Rin Chapin

        I agree that there is a bigger agenda at work. You’ll notice that numbers 17 and 20 are part of what I commented on: take control of schools and the press. They have done admirably, haven’t they?

        I also understand that people do need help. Last year I had to turn to a government (state) program for help when my doctors were screening me for two kinds of cancer. However, the goal should be for non-governmental organizations (and I don’t think they all have to be for profit) to be there for people who need it. What the government giveth, the government can taketh away. Instead our current government’s goal seems to be to increase the number of people it supports. Long-term that situation is not only unsustainable, but puts us into exactly what you posted–a people enslaved to their government. Please don’t think I’m not without understanding and compassion for your situation; like I said, I had to turn there also, but there need to be other alternatives in our society.

        • Runninbear

          Or for the actual citizens that these programs were created for!NOT ILLEGALS!Don’t get me wrong I am for Legal immigration.The USA has more than double the Visas and green cards than any two countries put together but to allow these who break the law to enter without any of the requirements that all the others do isn’t fair to those who spend 5 long years to come here and live the American dream legally!but to say how they should be treated as citizens depleting these programs to it’s breaking point,defrauding our tax loop holes and claiming deductions that they didn’t have( California Broke) .It’s time we take care and support our citizens!The more Amnesty we give the more will come and expect and demand the same or more!

          • http://www.facebook.com/michael.bloemer.18 Michael Bloemer

            The American Dream is to live off the Government. Anyone with two cents in the bank is a Greedy Anti-American Pig. Do these Liberals believe the @#$% they shovel?

  • goldsage

    You are right as usual!

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Georgia-Wellman/100001033182094 Georgia Wellman

    I love this Thomas Sowell Guy..He is Right On!



Copyright 2013 TPNN -

Tea Party News Network

All Rights Reserved

Privacy Policy

Terms of Use

Become a Sponsor