Dr. Carson’s Straight-Talk Earns Praise from Many, Scorn from the Left

Posted 02.11.13 by Greg Campbell, TPNN Contributor

By Greg Campbell
TPNN Contributor

On February 7th, 2013, famed neurosurgeon Dr. Benjamin Carson spoke to a crowd at the National Prayer Breakfast as President Obama and the First Lady sat at his side. Many are already aware of the doctor’s speech as it is being discussed in political circles and the speech itself is making the rounds on social media sites. Dr. Carson rose up from extreme poverty to become a gifted surgeon and the Director of Pediatric Neurosurgery at Johns Hopkins Hospital. His speech, however, revolved not the saving of lives, but the saving of a culture and nation in peril. For his honesty, he has incurred the wrath from the left.

President Obama was obviously not impressed with the good doctor’s simple solutions for fixing the country. However, Obama isn’t the only one; Illinois Democratic Representative Jan Schakowsky appeared on CNN’s State of the Union Sunday morning to dismiss the speech as “inappropriate.” She said,

“I think it’s really–not really an appropriate place to make this kind of political speech, and to invoke God as support for that kind of view. But I think of most of all the kind of message that he was giving shows a real empathy gap with where the American people are right now, and I think it’s reflective of where many of the Republicans and Tea Parties are right now, that we need to have an economy that works for everyone.”

However, an explanation for what God expects from mankind by Carson, a religious man of both faith and science, is precisely the kind of speech often heard at prayer breakfasts.

In just over 27 minutes, Carson outlined in amazingly effective and simplified terms how to address the most pressing issues that face our countries, and while the president was noticeably upset, the right (and even much of the left) has been thrilled with the straight-talk by Dr. Carson.

His speech began with a discussion of the pitfalls of political correctness. He discussed the value of freedom in expression and cited political correctness as a hindrance to the free exchange of ideas.

Dr. Carson then moved onto the importance of education, stating,

“Why is it so important that we educate our people? Because we don’t want to go down the pathway as so many pinnacle nations that have preceded us. I think particularly about ancient Rome. Very powerful. Nobody could even challenge them militarily, but what happened to them? They destroyed themselves from within. Moral decay, fiscal irresponsibility. They destroyed themselves. If you don’t think that can happen to America, you get out your books and you start reading, but you know, we can fix it.”

Dr. Carson then moved into discussing ways to remedy policies that are in obvious need of repair. Addressing the tax code, Carson explained,

“When I pick up my Bible, you know what I see? I see the fairest individual in the Universe, God, and he’s given us a system. It’s called tithe. Now we don’t necessarily have to do it 10% but it’s principle. He didn’t say, if your crops fail, don’t give me any tithes. He didn’t say, if you have a bumper crop, give me triple tithes. So there must be something inherently fair about proportionality. You make $10 Billion dollars you put in a Billion. You make $10 you put in $1 – of course, you gotta get rid of the loopholes, but now now some people say, that’s not fair because it doesn’t hurt the guy who made $10 Billion dollars as much as the guy who made $10. Where does it say you have to hurt the guy. He’s just put in a billion in the pot. We don’t need to hurt him.

It’s that kind of thinking – it’s that kind of thinking that has resulted in 602 banks in the Cayman Islands. That money needs to be back here, building our infrastructure and creating jobs – and we’re smart enough – we’re smart enough to figure out how to do that.”

Carson then moved swiftly into an area of his expertise: the medical field. He addressed healthcare issues, simply stating,

“Here’s my solution. When a person is born, give him a birth certificate, an electronic medical record and a health savings account [HSA], to which money can be contributed, pre-tax from the time you are born, to the time you die. When you die, you can pass it on to your family members so that when you’re 85 years old and you’ve got 6 diseases, you’re not trying to spend up everything. You’re happy to pass it on and nobody is talking about death panels. That’s number one. Also –

For the people who are indigent, who don’t have any money, we can make contributions to their HSA each month because we already have this huge pot of money instead of sending it to bureaucracy – let’s put it into HSAs. Now they have some control over their own health care and what do you think they’re going to do? They’re going to learn very quickly how to be responsible. When Mr. Jones gets that diabetic foot ulcer, he’s not going to the Emergency Room and blowing a big chunk of it. He’s going to go to the Clinic. He learns that very quickly – gets the same treatment. In the Emergency Room they send him out. In the Clinic they say, now let’s get your diabetes under control so that you’re not back here in three weeks with another problem. That’s how we begin to solve these kinds of problems. It’s much more complex than that, and I don’t have time to go into it all, but we can do all these things because we are smart people.”

Already, people on both the left and right, tired of the overly-complicated “solutions” to problems in government have come out in support of the simple solutions and straight talk offered by Dr. Carson. While establishment, “big government” Democrats are sure to hate the implication that Americans can retake sovereignty by reducing government’s presence and reaffirming cultural values, many are lavishing praise on the doctor and, as an illustration of the level of support Carson has received, the Wall Street Journal’s headline after the speech read, “Ben Carson for President.”



  • http://twitter.com/jackdrsm Jack Durish

    Progressives disapprove of a distinguished man speaking his mind? There’s a news flash for you.

  • http://www.facebook.com/willard.gray Willard Gray

    Dr. Carson’s comments were honest, factual, straight forward, enlightening, intellectual, heart felt, nonthreatening. Anyone of these attributes scares a liberal much less a litany. It was a great speech outlining problems and offering creditable solutions. This nation is badly wounded and needs the Great Physician . Count me as a Dr. Carson fan.

  • http://www.facebook.com/reginald.zenkewich Reginald Zenkewich

    concise and straight to thepoint and theObamanayshon is pissed off.

  • RevJules

    Dr. Carson is absolutely correct. He speaks with common sense and logic on solving the problems facing this nation. Of course, now he will be vilified by the left, and some on the right, who feel threatened by the solutions presented by Dr. Carson in this speech. The solutions would shrink the government and many would lose the power they now possess, along with the perks. The look on “O”s face during the speech was priceless and spoke volumes of what is probably in store for the good doctor. May God protect him and keep him safe.

  • Yit DeRp

    He should take an introductory econ course.

  • mary

    Ha, but there is a catch to it: you tithe the one(s) who have spiritually fed you. With God, we are talking spirituality. If you are not spiritually fed, then you do not have to tithe. Mho.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Joseph-Bons/1477664171 Joseph Bons

    Ben Carson for Presidet indeed !!!

  • gonecrazytoo

    After watching the movie about Dr. Carson’s life, I have nothing but respect for this man. He is the voice of reason that we ALL have been waiting for. Bravo!

  • liberalssuck

    We have a serious problem. That problem is a propaganda machine that works to cover Obama. We, the poeple need to get around this and spread our foundations and get us back on track.. I contact my reps and let them know how I feel and I do my best to back it up by voting against or for the said individual. To bad the unwashed masses do not get our message as we have a propaganda machine that constantly supports this tin pot dictator and his brood.

  • Hoosier Daddy

    “The left”, and particularly the leftwing propaganda machine, aka the “news” media, is 100% responsible for every problem this country faces right now. So, I just can’t have any empathy with the left’s view of this brilliant man.

    If the left’s beloved Messiah, Obama, was more like this man, he wouldn’t be the abject failure of a president that he is.

  • http://www.facebook.com/matt.sloan.9619 Matt Sloan

    What a guy! I’d definitely vote for this man to be our president-Sean Hannity is right! An humble brilliant physician presents biblically based solutions to some of our toughest sociopolitical problems. And no one can say he started out rich, or from anything but hard work and a Great mother. A true American success story. Dr Carson For President!

  • Russell H.

    How typical of Democratic Representative Jan Schakowsky to label refreshing ideas from Dr. Ben Carson as inappropriate and for her to determine that a prayer breakfast is not an appropriate place to invoke God, shows that she believes that God shouldn’t be invoked at all. The left is increasingly becoming known as the “Godless” party as they are becoming less and less tolerant of anyone who puts God first. If Representative Jan Schakowsky thinks that she is going to rally the thought police to silence Dr. Ben Carson or any Christian, think again. Her statements as well as any liberals statements against God and Christians are only going to strengthen our resolve.

  • debi godsey

    Dr Carson gave a BRILLIANT speech, but I bet his wise advise will be ignored by the left and that they will continue on with their blind “leadership” as always. It’s how we got into the mess we are in as a country. If Dr Carson runs for president, I WILL vote for him! He has wisdom that can come only from God. His speech is by far the most intelligent speech I have heard come out of Washington DC in years!

  • http://www.facebook.com/riverrat37 David D Hansen

    IM PROUD THAT DOC CARSON WOULD STAND UP FOR GOD AND

    COUNTRY WHATS HIS NAME AND ALL THE DUMMIES THAT VOTED A

    COUPL TIMES FOR HIM

  • http://www.facebook.com/ralph.hough.77 Ralph Hough

    K.I.S.S… as it should be with a people who are responsible… and who knows, maybe we will get smarts in the process!

  • Anna

    And to think Dr. Ben Carson is Black, and with the intelligence to back it up. How come he is not touting the race or slave cards that so many poor pitty party blacks do? Because is had the foresight to see what he could become and that slavery was over 200 years ago and he stood on his own two feet to become a man of respect without being a bully

  • http://www.facebook.com/fowlerd97 Roger Fowler

    LOGIC AND COMMON SENSE,THE PRESIDENT HAS NEITHER.JUST SITTING THERE WITH THAT HATEFULL SMUG LOOK ON HIS FACE

  • ltbl123

    Ben Carson has gifted hands, and gifted speech, and he didn’t receive them from the government he received them from God. His mother taught him to honor God by being the best he could be. It is obvious she suceeded. Praise God that Ben is willing to honor God even when so few are willing to do the same.

  • blogengeezer

    Mao Tse Jung put up with the Socialized ‘system’ the USA is now embracing, for only so long, due to impending bankruptcy and approaching starvation. Mao finally, out of desperation started his ‘Great Leap.. ‘Forward’.. (sound familiar?) ‘The Red Brigades’.

    They systematically banged on doors, dragging out ‘Everyone’ of the perpetually dependency addicted, including their uncontrolled, subsidized ‘spawn’, from the dysfunctional, crime infested Urban centers, including their ‘enablers’ the wealth Redistribution obsessed, social studies ‘Professors’. Of course his political ‘enemies’ were included in the ‘cleansing’.

    They were ALL marched (no buses, no trains) out to the Agrarian countryside for ‘reeducation’ on survival…WORK.. Most Never returned. Maybe they enjoyed the Country Living??

    Prof Rummel estimates from 1 to 38 million became ‘compost’. Possibly the US office of Homeland Security is the new (well armed) ‘Red Brigades’? 30 million across the USA is only 1 out of 10, barely noticeable…barely..

    Dr Carlson offers another, more ‘survivable’ alternative. Is anyone listening?

  • CLAYCE

    God Bless Dr. Carson. He’s a national Treasure!

  • http://www.facebook.com/maxwell.friedlander Maxwell Friedlander

    I guess the Left doesn’t like it when any one criticizes Hussein.

  • Guest

    Applauding Dr. Carson. Voice of sense!I I think a second obama term is a most disastrous for America, but our efforts to ellect responsible devoted prez unfortunately failed again. Ppl still did not wake up and believe in WHAT?Did his obamacare help elderlies, kids or so on? I am sick and tired of talking, talking, explaining ppl all consiquences of having a big government and socialist ideas spreading the wealth around. They don’t want to listen to and, I assume, very poor educated on the matter of history. This country is Beautiful and don’t let anyone to mess it
    around.

  • http://profile.yahoo.com/4FVCXOYDQPXFJWOGIRXAQOYRPM Brian

    Scorn??? From the LEFT? Noooo…it can’t be. Do you want to off a liberal? Simply start spouting off common sense, evidence, truth, responsibility, equal opporTUNity, (okay, I haven’t got room for all of it)… you get my point. Simple, honest, conservative principles, that are even lost on the right in Washington, that really work….I’m surprised the RINO’s aren’t jumping on the bashwagon.

  • rascallyrabbit

    This country is so ready for a “New Common Sense and Constitution Party” or a “New Common Sense and Freedom Party”. Time to jettison the 2 major parties we have now, they are un repairable. Keep the talk on the issues and solutions. I would vote for this man in a heartbeat. And as for those a that remember another up and comer out of nowhere, the difference this time is that this man has a history that is known, actually has had a real career with real accomplishments, and a moral compass that is governed by God, not his political advisors.

  • http://www.facebook.com/mary.a.demarco Mary Ann DeMarco

    Does Jan Schakowsky think they have the right economy that works for the country now? I’m with Dr. Carson.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Herb-Stevens/1167330913 Herb Stevens

    WOW! Dr. Carson gets it right. What a positive contrast to Obama.

  • http://www.facebook.com/dlmullins70 Dreama Whatley

    Applauding Dr. Carson!!

  • Carl M. Zapffe

    I generally don’t listen to long speeches on Youtube, but Dr. Ben Carson’s inspiring and spot on speech was the best 27 minutes that I have spent in a long time.

  • http://www.facebook.com/doug.swanson.77 Doug Swanson

    I thoroughly enjoyed his speech. He absolutely represented the thoughts and values of the majority of Americans who actually work for a living and are in charge of their own lives. And the socialist in the White House had to be squirming. I can’t imagine how Obama let that happen. He who is such an arrogant control freak.

  • John Joseph Callahan

    In 27 minutes, this Doctor made more sense than obama has mad since he has been in office. This man is a real American. Obama? A fraud.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Ann-Wilson-Kingsley/100000397000382 Ann Wilson Kingsley

    It would be very hard for those making only $10,000 per year to pay $1,000 of that in taxes. We need to end the behemoth Federal Government instead. Down-size the Federal Government so that no one is required to pay unaffordable taxes, whether he is poor or a billionaire. Are you sure Dr. Carson isn’t working for Obama? He makes Conservatives look really bad because he doesn’t provide the complete solution. So far, he is just punishing people with our out of control Federal Government.

    • http://www.facebook.com/leslie.stavrowsky Leslie Stavrowsky

      We definintely need a simplification of our tax code. It is a complete mess. Besides, everyone who uses public roads and takes advantage of any public government services should pay SOME taxes. Part of our fiscal problems are caused by the fact that over 40% of our US population pays NO TAXES at all. This is just not right. Every citizen should pay SOME taxes, put some skin in the game. Only the highest upper 3% of income earners in this country pay over 50% of ALL the federal taxes collected. Something is very wrong with this picture. Every citizen should pay SOME taxes.
      I agree that our Federal Government needs to be downsized as well. The Federal Government has grown by 25% under the Obama administration. Washington, D.C. jobs are just flourishing, and the rest of the country is suffering. We have over 24 million people out of work right now, and that situation has not gotten any better under the last 4 years of the Obama administration.

      • JMerklin

        The flat tax is not the answer. The answer is a national sales tax. That way – EVERYONE pays whether they’re poor, whether they’re criminals, or even people visiting our country. EVERYONE PAYS…..

        • http://www.facebook.com/tim.cognito.52 Tim Cognito

          Tax has always served as a disincentive. That’s why we have such high taxes on liquor and cigarettes. Supposedly a disincentive; though it never works well unless it’s applied to something that’s addictive or mind altering. Government knows this. Put a fat tax on anything else and you see a lot less of it. Taxing income is a disincentive to earning any. Put a tax only on what you spend, and it encourages savings. More savings means less need for Social Security and welfare benefits, etc. It also means less for the government to squander and misappropriate.
          Carson’s health plan makes sense because it keeps the money in the hands of those that need it with HSA’s. Obamacare takes it from everyone, spends as little as it needs to (death panels) and keeps the rest in the hands of the politicians to squander and misappropriate. That’s why “you have to vote for it to find out what’s in it”. If the people who actually pay for this knew (closed doors sessions/no internet before/no CSPAN), it never would have happened.

          • JMerklin

            I agree. Carson’s plan is the right way. Obamacare has nothing at all to do with Health Care. It has to do with contolling the people. Google this: Obamacare vs Hitler T4. You’ll see they’re nearly identical…. Obama needs to be brought to justice along with most of congress and the supreme court. I only wish that Dr Carson had said to Obama’s face – You sir cannot prove you are even an American citizen and you sir, need to be impeached and brought to justice. I sure would have said it. Obama lost his American citizenship when he was a kid and moved to Indonesia…. You can not have dual citizenship back then, especially with a country such as Indonesia who were blackballed with sanctions against them.

    • http://www.facebook.com/bob3653 Robert Strong

      What tree are you hanging out in? Dr. Carson was making an example that the uninformed voter could understand.

    • David Cram

      Seems to me that a person making $10,000 already pays more than a tenth of that in taxes, when you count sales tax, gasoline tax, payroll tax, etc., etc., etc.

    • oldguy

      With a ten percent national sales tax everyone would be taxed according to their spending habits. The rich will still buy Mercedes, us poor will buy used cars. With exemptions on food and medicines the old and sick among us would not be penalized and would be able to pay the eighty three dollars per month on things we buy. I have to live on just over 900.00 per month after a whole lifetime of paying into the SS system and I’d go for that in a heartbeat. It’s not regressive and would be revenue positive. Not only that but you’d eliminate the IRS totally and completely. Check out their budget and put all that money back into the coffers and it’s a win-win situation for us all.

    • ltbl123

      Please explain how anyone especially the government can provide a complete solution to affordable health care? Is the 20K a year estimate of cost by the IRS for a family of 5 affordable?

  • GimmeABreak

    I wonder if Jan listens to herself when she talks. First, her remarks made it to the top of the Lame Comments by the Mindless list when she clearly couldn’t address a single issue Dr. Carson brought up. All she did was whine about how she didn’t think this was the right place…she was wrong about that, of course. But then she made this statement: “But I think most of all the kind of message that he was giving shows a real empathy gap [huh?!] with where the American people are right now, and I think it’s reflective of where many of the Republican and Tea Parties are right now, that we need to have an economy that works for everyone.” I’m no scholar, and certainly not a genius, but I know a badly-constructed sentence when I see one. Rambling. Yeah, that’s the first word that comes to mind.

    Next, she uses the term “Tea Parties.” There’s more than one? Or was she referring to actual afternoon social gatherings? Anyway, her next phrase really cracked me up. Because of her poor sentence structure, she ended up saying the opposite of what she obviously meant. Grammatically, she said this message reflected the fact that Republicans and Tea Party members (notice how I corrected that) are at the place where they know we need to have an economy that works for everyone.

    Dang. And these people claim to be smarter than the rest of us? Gag.

    • SourPea

      Actually, if you read between the lines Jan is saying: “If you are black you aren’t allowed to “go up” in this world … and if you do you need to spend your life apologizing for your success.” This wonderful Doctor is the personification of the American Dream and Obama is jealous.

  • Joanne

    Too bad Dr. Carson won’t run for President, what a great speech, right on target, isn’t it wonderful that someone finally stood up and told the truth? Sure won’t come from the Lame Stream Media.

  • constantvigil

    Ben Carson ‘s speech eviscerated many of Obama’s propaganda lies about America with several examples of an American dream with dignity for everyone!!!

    Ben Carson is trully a great man and shows Obama to be a fraud and a small man – as well as his supporters: mainstream media, etc. – by comparison: Ben Carson brought himself up from far worse conditions than Obama with honor and integrity as opposed to Obama’s lies and moral depravity!!

    • rascallyrabbit

      What Obama lacked in his upbringing were parents with a moral compass and devotion to their child’s well being above their own. Seems pretty clear from what we do know about Obama’s childhood, his parents were parents in name only. While I totally oppose nearly everything Obama is for, I do think he and Michelle try to be good parents. Too bad they don’t understand that throwing money at welfare mothers does not help children. Carson had a good mother in every sense of the word, so, in fact, he was very wealthy in what mattered.

  • EllenBernal

    Dr. Carson is an educated man with many qualities. I am greatful that he told the President what his policy will do for Americans. Yes they will go down the drain most likely under his leadership as the Romans did when they where in full power. African Americans need to understand that they can not continue living on welfare. Who is paying for their SS? Stop producing welfare Children and get to work, make something of yourself besides being on drugs and crime sprees. America does not owe you anything you owe America all you have to create a great Nation. Do you really want a Communist Nation where they make all your decisions from birth to death? Just Think about it, it’s not funny.

    • ConscienceCit

      AND he is not a lawyer!! YEAH!

    • oldguy

      Bill Cosby’s been saying that very same thing for 30 years and nobody has listened to him. What makes us believe they will start now??

    • SourPea

      I agree, but it’s not just black Americans that think of welfare as a way of life. Too many people choose irresponsiblity as a way of life.

  • Jed54

    Why is everyone surprised the left scorned.. when you have a disease such as Liberism,,, your friggen sick… terminal… Super Obummer does not have an open mind.. its clogged with s**t…. he needs a good shot of air thru any ear to blow it out…. He’s a born loser.. Born to failure… He sucks!!

    • SourPea

      Actually, he scorns independence. This President has gone through life unable or unwilling to develop a “self”. How sad….and what a piss-poor role model.

  • http://profiles.google.com/joe.texan Joe Henderson

    Ben Carson for President, Thomas Sowell and Walter Williams as part of his administration, and Andrew Napolitano on the Supreme Court.

    • Waldo the Pig

      We had our Herman Cann. The Media, Democrates, Progressives, and Leftists left no rock unturned on order to destroy him. Intelligent, hard working, successful Blacks are the worse threats to them. Jesus knew this that none of us have not sinned when he said “He who have not sinned can cast the first stone.”

      • SourPea

        Yes, but whoever gets the word out first is the one who is believed. That is why Jesus told the parable of the “Unjust Judge”. Most people are unjust judges.

    • SourPea

      Now THERE are some real leaders!

  • Ida temple

    Its time for those to come forward and speak up to save this great nation. I applaud Dr. Carson for not allowing his poor life as a child to hold him back. We all need to do that; no matter who we are.

  • horseridingplains

    Sounds like the Doctor makes sense–bama shoud have been squirming- but as narcissistic as he is–he only believes he himself is right and does not need to compromise(his words, not mine). Nice gawd/king/tyrant complex and Benghazi still will not just go away–it does matter

  • Peter Locke

    It’s encouraging to read about people like Dr Carson. I hope the President listens to him with an open mind.

    • http://www.facebook.com/dean.braun.35 Dean Braun

      He won’t.

    • ConscienceCit

      I hope Valerie Jarrett, the puppet master, learned something!

      • 1Anastasia

        she is an idiot that won’t learn anything, she and obuttma are programmed to think the way that they think.

    • 1Anastasia

      he wont-he will consider how to shut him up….

      • JMerklin

        right – the same way he has shut other people up – by killing them.

    • CLAYCE

      Somewhere down the road some Federal Agency will audit is books for tax evasion or distribution of prescriptions or jay walking. That’s how the evil Chicago crowd does it!

      • Mac

        I hope that does not happen to this brilliant and courageous man but it would not be surprising if it did.

    • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=516859771 John Sweet

      Peter your a funny guy! to even think Obama would consider the truth when his agenda is to destroy the nation and make it subservient to the Muslim Brotherhood

    • Chrisopher Mountain-Riojas

      He won’t he is too arrogant. With arrogance comes disgrace.

    • http://www.facebook.com/willard.gray Willard Gray

      don’t hold your breath, Peter.



Copyright 2013 TPNN -

Tea Party News Network

All Rights Reserved

Privacy Policy

Terms of Use

Become a Sponsor