Report: Boehner Caves on Tax Increases for High Income Earners

Posted 12.16.12 by Jennifer Burke, TPNN Contributor

By Jennifer Burke
TPNN Contributor

In a move that is sure to anger conservative Republicans and the tea party movement, Reuters is reporting that Speaker John Boehner offered a tax hike on high income earners beginning January 1st to President Obama in exchange for entitlement reform. Politico is reporting that the deal offered by Boehner will not include an extension of unemployment benefits nor would it include a raising of the debt ceiling, both of which are unwavering demands by Obama and the Democrats. Obama has reportedly turned the deal down.

This report is counter to what Boehner has been stating to the media over the past few weeks and comes on the heels of the No New Taxes press conference held by TheTeaParty.net, Senator Rand Paul (R-KY), Congressmen Louie Gohmert (R-TX), Paul Broun (R-GA), John Fleming (R-LA), Tim Huelskamp (R-KS), and numerous other tea party leaders. At this press conference, these conservative leaders stated adamantly that they would not support any tax increases on the American people. Each had previously taken made a promise to their constituents to not raise taxes by signing the Taxpayer Protection Pledge through Americans for Tax Reform.

Senator Jim DeMint (R-SC), who recently announced that he will be resigning from his Senate seat to become president of the conservative think tank Heritage Foundation, stated on Thursday that Boehner should be worried about losing the speakership. This newest report will likely increase talk regarding whether his speakership is in jeopardy.

Jay Severin, from TheBlaze, asked DeMint whether Republicans had a plan B in place just in case Obama did win re-election. According to DeMint, there was no such preparation on the part of the GOP.

“We have not had that plan you talked about,” DeMint said. “We can’t keep playing defense all the time, negotiating with ourselves, allowing the president to not have a plan.”

Republicans need to stop conceding on their values and conducting backdoor negotiations, DeMint said.

“The house should have passed a bill that we thought was best for the country, and probably should have gone home during this lame duck,” DeMint said on the failure to still not have a solution for the debt and Fiscal Cliff. ”It’s important in a political sphere to back up what you say, It’s really about power–whether we like it or not.”

Back in 2009, President Obama stated that raising taxes during a recession is the last thing you would want to do. The economy is even more unstable and fragile now than it was then. Which begs the question….what will truly be accomplished by raising taxes on high income earners? For an answer to this question, one only needs to turn to the answer that then candidate Obama gave during a debate between Democrat candidates for president in 2008. When reminded of the fact that raising capital gains taxes has historically resulted in decreased revenue while the lowering of it resulted in increased revenue, Obama’s response left many perplexed. He stated, “It’s not about revenue; it’s about fairness.”

We must not forget that response by the man who would become president as it gives tremendous insight into his view of taxation. Regardless of what he states now, it is not about deficit reduction nor is it about increased revenue. In fact, it is not even about fairness because we have 47% of the population that pays no income tax. It is about control, government intrusion, and furthering his class warfare ideology that’s rooted in Marxism. That, my friends, is a dangerous thing and the GOP must stand strong against it.



  • Pingback: http://answers.yahoo.com/question/index?qid=20130111065232AApIhO2

  • Pingback: туроператор по израилю

  • Pingback: туроператор по израилю

  • http://www.facebook.com/mreyesgowing Michele Reyes Gowing

    STEP DOWN ALREADY BOEHNER. YOU ARE WEAK!!!

  • Joe R

    We need to CUT SPENDING & RAISE TAXES, BUT MOST IMPORTANT IS TO CUT SPENDING!

  • http://www.facebook.com/jeff.caldwell.5680 Jeff Caldwell

    Bohner if you give in to this you are a BIG Wuss

  • http://www.facebook.com/gerrie.rue Gerrie Rue

    Boehner caved but Obama rejected it. Obama wants more. He once said that raising the debt limit was a sign of leadership failure, and yet he wants to do that also! Not only that, but he wants to extend unemployment benefits, and include illegal aliens in that program. And he wants more foreign aid. When will this incompetent (put your own word here) get enough? When the country goes absolutely broke? Well, we are already there!!!!

  • http://www.facebook.com/dowd.waid Dowd Waid

    Boehner better not cave, bring on the fiscal cliff, it is nothing more than a democrat party ploy to bait the republicans into doing what they want. Just as they did to Bush #1 when he said no new taxes, as soon as it cam out of his mouth the door was opened for them to raise taxes like crazy. They will do the same thing here. If Boehner caves, he’s gotta go as Speaker and get someonw in there that can explain to the President that spending starts in the House, NOT the White House.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Linda-Bullard/100001100155468 Linda Bullard

    Raising taxes is about increasing the size and scope of government and that is the aim of most politicians. They give lipservice to cutting government all the while voting to give more power to it. The only solution now is for people to stand up and say no more.

  • loreneparlier

    do not give in please we are counting on you

  • Diane Preston

    I to have heard about the wasteful spending of our government and white house. Stop sending money overseas. Bring our troups home and cover the borders instead. Cut out the government spending on programs we do not need. Cut the staff in half at the white house, who needs so many assistants, Quit giving medicare and food stamps to illegals. If they want to live here go home, fill out and apply for citizenship from there. If you pass then you are move then welcome to come here and work.

  • Pingback: Reports: Boehner Caves - TPNN | The Tea Party News Network

  • http://www.facebook.com/lance.hottrod Lance Hottrod

    I have read for years about all the wasteful spending our government does and now under O’bummer it is worse than ever!! If all this waste was cut out and totally unnecessary “research grants” on meaningless projects was cut, in addition to all the foreign aid to especially Muslim countries we might stand a chance of treading water long enough to make some progress with paying down the debt. Even the Congressional Budget Office has stated that Obamacare will cost 2-1/2 times more than originally thought and that it will ultimately be unsustainable. Couple this with O’bummers economic policies that are strangling business in America and it is a recipe for disaster. But that’s what Obama wants – - to ruin America. Actions speak louder than words!

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/William-OBrien/100000728823601 William O’Brien

    This isn’t about revenue; it is about “fairness”, as found in the small mind of an Indonesian expatriate masquerading as an American president. Unfortunately, Speaker Boehner’s position is precarious; vote to tax higher income taxpayers at a higher rate and we conservatives bash him, don’t vote for the tax rate increase and everyone’s taxes are automatically increased. The new congress will introduce legislation to decrease taxes on everyone but the wealthy and Speaker Boehner will have to go along. His situation is dire and I would not want to be in his shoes, as I do not know which way to jump.

  • foghat

    OUR COUNTRY IS GONE !!!

  • Eddie

    I’m retired and on a fixed income no where close to the top 2%, but I would be willing to pay more taxes to see some serious Entitlement reform. I see people to lazy to work riding the social security, welfare and unemployment money train everyday. Less can only support more for so long and then its revolt.

    • http://www.facebook.com/mike.becker.900 Mike Becker

      you’re retired and on fixed income… and you’re complaining about people riding the social security train? i think my head just exploded… well, it would, if i didn’t have to go back to work and pay the government 1/3 of every dollar i make to support you..

      • Eddie

        Well I worked 39years for that retirement and my complaint is with the people I see that claim their kids are mental so they can live on their SSI. Also with all these drawing long term unemployment because they want a position not a job.
        Sent from my U.S. Cellular® Android-powered phone

        • Guest

          the money you paid into the system is already gone, used to support the
          previous generation. i’ve paid into that very same system my entire
          adult life, and that money is being used to support you lazy moochers. i’m never going to see social security benefits, so why should i
          pay for you to see yours? you just want big government to take care of
          you for the rest of your lives, instead of WORKING and taking some
          PERSONAL RESPONSIBILITY for your own finances.

        • http://www.facebook.com/mike.becker.900 Mike Becker

          Socialist Security and Medicommunism are the biggest expenses the federal government has, after military spending. mental health benefits, and the housing/food talked about by the above poster are *nothing* compared to the amount of wealth being transfered from my generation to yours by your best friends, the democrats.

          • Eddie

            Not sure what you’re referring to in regards to my generation. Since I have never drawn a dime of unemployment or social security. I do know retired folks on social security and Medicare but they are in their 60′s and 70s and paid in to it during their working life. I am a conservative Republican and do not support the liberal agenda. Hence that is why I have an issue with people drawing entitlements they haven’t earned. As a Christian I know that God’s word says we have to take care of the needy but it also says a man who WILL NOT work shall not eat.
            Sent from my U.S. Cellular® Android-powered phone

      • http://www.facebook.com/people/Linda-Bullard/100001100155468 Linda Bullard

        Well Mike the people on social security were forced to pay into the system all through our working careers. How is something we paid for an entitlement. I did not willingly give my money for social security it was taken from me before I ever got my check. Entitlement is giving money, homes, food, medical care, ect to people who have never worked and will never work as long as the government provides for them. Government wasteful spending, regulations, and government retirment is killing the private industries and as long as this continues America will decline.

        • http://www.facebook.com/mike.becker.900 Mike Becker

          it’s an entitlement because you are receiving more money from the system than you ever paid into it. that’s hardworking americans’ tax money that’s just being redistributed to you, because you support socialist security, because you weren’t smart enough to save for your own retirement. So yeah, entitlement reform will never happen because of PEOPLE LIKE YOU.

          • http://www.facebook.com/kay.d.strebe Kay Dee Strebe

            I am not on Soc. Sec. yet, but I have paid into it for 37 years and my husband paid into it for 48 years before he died. Let me tell you, you will not get what you paid into it and you certainly don’t get more back than what you paid into it. It is a forced retirement fund that you pay interest on and money that you pay taxes on twice. Social Security is not entitlement. What is entitlement is the lifetime salary that we pay every person that serves in Congress, The Supreme Court, and the White House and not one dime of their retirement came out of their pockets or pay, it came out of ours.

          • http://www.facebook.com/mike.becker.900 Mike Becker

            If you aren’t collecting benefits yet, then no you won’t get what you paid into it. but if you started collecting benefits between 1985 and 1999, then you certainly are collecting more than you paid into it

          • http://www.facebook.com/robert.law.5439087 Robert Law

            Mike: I would hope that you are just as adamant about SS benefits and those immigrants that also never paid into the system yet receive SS money from this administration! Please tell me, what is you opinion on those soldiers, like myself, that become permanently disabled through war and receive VA benefits? I never paid into that system…am I a freeloader like you think everyone is?

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Chris-Holley/1178389425 Chris Holley

    NO new taxes for anyone….You’re going to kill small businesses. Its not a tax problem (except for ones who pay no tax, they should pay taxes too), It’s a spending problem.

    • http://www.facebook.com/robert.law.5439087 Robert Law

      Chris…everyone pays taxes. However, some receive a refund that is equal to the amount (or more!) than what they paid in to begin with. What people must remember is that EVERYONE pays initially.

  • http://www.facebook.com/barry.watson.503 Barry Watson

    another rino bowing to the demagogs in d.c.!!

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=1800263526 Martha Benton

    Only thing missing in the above picture is his hanky dabbing his tears. He is such a wimp and a disgrace to America. Why are they keeping him as Speaker? I know thousands of faxes have been sent to Congress to kick his butt out and put somebody in that has some balls and not a pocket full of hankies.

  • forrest

    WHY DID WE KEEP A WOOSE IN CONGRESS IS WHAT I AM WONDERING AT THIS MINUTE. WITHOUT SOME GIVING ON THE LIBERALS SPEND SPEND SPEND FRONT LET US GO OVER THE PREVERBAL CLIFF. MAYBE THAT WILL WAKE UP THE HAPPY GO LUCKY LIBERAL SPENDERS IN WASHINGTON DC.

  • Guest

    well i think the eason that kid took attion away from gov on georges b day was to screw the american tax payier

    • Alan Lynn

      What did you just say? I cannot understand it!

  • Alan Lynn

    Higher taxes on millionaires or a poor nation? I’ll take the taxes. It is the extreme part of the right wing that makes us sane moderates look bad.

    • http://www.facebook.com/daryl.woodrum Daryl Woodrum

      okay, you want higher taxes on millionairs…please explain to me how it would help to tax all millionairs at 100% if the government would spend it all in 88 days….The problem is not that we tax too little, it is that we spend too much…

      • http://www.facebook.com/mike.becker.900 Mike Becker

        uh… in Econ 101 (Intro to Macroeconomics) you also learn that government spending via direct investment in industry (Keynesian economics) has better outcomes than the Friedman model, both in long and short term. And that taxing top earners and corporations doesn’t actually ‘kill jobs’. Of course this depends on starting with a stable economy. Cases – China, Germany, and the USA 1944-1970.

  • http://www.facebook.com/JeanHD Jean Gray

    We need to get rid of him and all so-called conservatives like this man. I will never again vote for any of them who cave.

    • http://www.facebook.com/john.lacharite John Lacharite

      Be careful what you wish for Jean. Olympia “Maine Rino” Snowe just retired and the idiots here in Maine voted for “independent” Angus King, our former Gov. He left us in a world of debt, made himself rich on windmills on taxxpayer dimes. He is about as independent as Nancy Pelosi! I would have rather kept the Rino in this case!!!

  • Picacho Willy

    to negotiate persons have to make compromises so that both parties to the problem reach an agreement. Let’s see what agreement is reached before we throw the speaker into the bay with the tea. We only have 1/3 of the power of the government in the House yet many act as if the President and the Senate are Republican, too. We lost the election. 47% of the people pay no income taxes. We must negotiate. We must compromise. We must deal with reality and reach a solution with which we as Americans can live.

  • http://www.facebook.com/marta.moulder Marta Moulder

    He didn’t cave. He followed the script. This was the plan all along. Had to try and make us all believe he would do his best, when his best was never put on the table. Great acting job though. I’m so sick of these political puppets and all this pure crap that masquerades as concern for “the middle class”. The people are the least of their concerns. Why should they care? They already have salaries that probably would take ten of us ten years to make what they do in one month. You don’t hear anything about any of them taking pay-cuts. No,we all must tighten our belts. That’s fine if the President wants to go on vacation, but he should pay for it out of HIS money. That’s fair isn’t it? Sure it is. I guess Benghazi distraction worked for them. Killed several million birdies with one stone.

  • gloria

    thanks guy . We counted on you

  • Pingback: The Tea Party - SURVEY: Will Boehner Cave?

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=100000608725044 Elizabeth Giovengo

    I don’t blame you, you have to deal with people that want nothing but unlimited power and GOP has so little of it now. I can say I am sorry to hear about this. I think that the tax laws need changed to include that people rich and GE have to pa something, my god you work and earn in America and you pay not one dime in taxes? Really?? All of the rest of us have to pay, a fair FLAT tax for all working Americans is what is needed, but as usual the RICh continue to get more yachts and the rest of us down grade from hamburger to SPAM again. REALLY I wish all of you would get your heads out of your rears!! !

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=1431384329 Loretta L Vickers

    We need a stronger new speaker!!!

  • Critter

    why don’t the republicans have a backbone to stand up for what they say they believe in?

    • http://www.facebook.com/people/Linda-Bullard/100001100155468 Linda Bullard

      Because all any politician now days care about is reelection to their cushy job. Let the rest of the country suffer but I am still gona get mine must be their motto. Do they cut one dime from their crazy spending of taxpayers money for their purks. The answer is no their solutions are take more and give less.

  • CLAYCE

    Boehner’s sun tan juice is still holding up, but he’s got a thousand cuts, and hasn’t the sense to know he’s being played like a fiddle. At this point I question his intelligence!

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Carol-Fryer/100000156546455 Carol Fryer

    The thing that really gets me mad is that they keep saying people are complaining because they want Bone head to cave, to compromise…..media perception engineering, as usual spinning the facts into what they want them to be.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Carol-Fryer/100000156546455 Carol Fryer

    Well this time hes caved in so many times before..hes bending over once again to kiss Obummers butt and Obummer just moves and laughs and says…..What…? You thought I was giving you something? You get nothing. And Bone head just sits in the corner and cries. Time to get a real conservative and not a rino.

  • outofsteam

    And just when will Obama implement Boehner’s terms of not extending unemployment or raise the debt ceiling? Never! Ole Johnny boy talks out of both sides of his mouth. There was never any question in my mind that he will do his usual nothing! I’m not in that “rich” 2% and never will be but this is ridiculous! What comes after that? Raise taxes on those making $75,000. Not me either.

  • newSam

    John Boenher caving? This is news? Since when?

  • Kim Couch

    Time to kick White Flag Johnny out of the Speaker position and out of the
    House .Shame on you Johnny white flag Shame your disgrace to all
    conservatives and to the American people.

    • http://www.facebook.com/bobby.franklin.33 Bobby Franklin

      And replace him with another face that will do the same thing !

  • dankster

    boehner caved. why am i not surprized.



Copyright 2013 TPNN -

Tea Party News Network

All Rights Reserved

Privacy Policy

Terms of Use

Become a Sponsor